Are we more keen to build solidarity with our enemies than our allies?
Hi everyone, I just came back from Race Forward’s amazing Facing Race conference where Stacey Abrams, W. Kamau Bell, and Tressie McMillan Cottom keynoted. It was hopeful and joyful, especially considering the midterms, and exactly what I and many people needed.
The conference had an ongoing theme of building solidarity, and there were many brilliant workshops and speakers discussing strategies and tactics for how we go about doing that, including a creative project called the Solidarity Love Languages.
The concept of solidarity has been on my mind quite a bit these past few years. I’ve noticed a pattern, not just in our sector, but also in politics and in the world in general. Specifically, it seems a lot of people would rather spend time and energy building solidarity with those who are fundamentally opposed to their values than those who are more aligned. And always to the detriment of equity.
A couple of examples. After the midterms, it seems many of the Democrats who have won office are way more interested in working with Republicans than they are to working with progressives, promising “bipartisanship” while snubbing those calling for an end to genocide, AIPAC funding, data centers, and for holding accountable those who have tried repeatedly to destroy democracy. A progressive leader on Instagram remarked something like, “Leave it to Democrats to turn a Blue wave into a purple wave.” (Apologies, I could not find that post to do the proper attribution).
Meanwhile, in our line of work, a few months ago I shared on LinkedIn this article that discusses how the right wing has been pouring money into “civil discourse” on college campuses as a tactic to distract liberals from how extreme the right has become. In the comment section, I got into a heated exchange with a dude who is also a person of color and pro-Palestine. He was blaming progressives like me for the rise of Trump and for the genocide, and he was angry that we disparage the work of “building bridges” with MAGA and other right-wing groups. Two of his comments really stood out:
“I have made a promise: every time I see social justice warriors disparage the work of peacebuilders, I will meet them on their turf, using the same tactics of strategic polarization and stigmatization to counter them.”
And:
“Given my identity, it was not easy for me to explore new pathways with Zionists, Southern Baptists, the Koch network, the ADL, and others, because I was likely viewed as enemy number one by many of them.”
So let me get this straight: This colleague, who is probably more aligned with people like me than he is with diametrically-opposite-in-values groups, including right-wing hate groups, has vowed to oppose people like me with everything he got, including "stigmatization." Meanwhile, he’s working hard building bridges with these orgs, including again right-wing hate groups, even though most of them probably view people like him (and me) as “enemy number one”?
This is a pattern that I’ve observed a lot in our sector and liberal spaces in general. We sometimes strangely give move grace to those who are fundamentally opposed to the existence of equity and justice, than we do to the imperfect people who are on our side fighting for those things.
In 2017, Frances Lee wrote a powerful article called “Excommunicate Me from the Church of Social Justice.” Lee points out social justice activists’ propensity to seek purity and punish those who don’t embody it perfectly, ingrained habit of reproducing colonialist logic and tactics, and weaponization of “sacred texts” to justify mistreating one another though we are on the same side. I’ve experienced it myself, getting flak for using the wrong platform or terminology, or for not being up to date on the latest social justice concept or agreement.
Meanwhile, I can think of a few reasons why we sometimes gravitate towards building bridges with people who are far less aligned in values:
Self-preservation: Those who are fundamentally opposed to our values pose more of a threat, so it’s evolutionarily more sensible to appease to them to neutralize the danger they may pose, whereas the people on our side, even if they get very mad or frustrated, are much less likely going to try to do us significant harm. It’s kind of like how many of us from marginalized communities have been trained to and will instinctively be nicer and more polite when we deal with the police than when we deal with our own siblings. Our siblings may annoy or insult us, but the police may kill us if they get upset.
Lowered expectations: There is the expression “know better, do better.” We expect those who have our values to have been exposed to various conversations and readings, so they should know better, so they need to do better, and if they don’t, well it’s their fault for being behind. On the other hand, we don’t expect people those whose values don’t align with ours to know better (about white supremacy, injustice, racism, misogyny, etc.), so we don’t expect them to do better. They are given the grace we give toddlers, as we assume they don't know better. Even if toddlers break vases and draw on walls, they still seem innocent and teachable.
Fake niceness. People who spout cruelty, racism, misogyny, and so on are adept at being strategically nice in order to use people to advance their goals. They are welcoming, courteous, and charismatic, and they make you feel special and smart for being friendly with them. Contrast this with how activists sometimes treat one another, and this fake niceness can be seductive. It's only when it's too late does the mask fall off and people realize they've been bamboozled and are next on the chopping block.
Intermittent rewards: This is the psychological phenomenon where rewards are given unpredictably and inconsistently, which causes people to be more motivated to engage. It helps explains why people are addicted to gambling, for example; slot machines rarely and unpredictably pay out, which causes people to want to keep playing. The same way, being nice to people who hate your guts occasionally pays off with possibly changing their mind, or getting some praise from them, or whatever. And since these rewards are so rare, versus when working with allies, it makes them even more attractive.
Whatever the reasons, this is a destructive habit. We have seen throughout history that trying to build bridges with or "have a big enough tent to include" those who are fundamentally opposed to the existence of trans people, immigrants and refugees, people of color, disabled people, and others on the margins, seldom if ever works. If anything, they see it is as weakness, and they exploit it, such as through creating the Civility Industrial Complex and convincing funders to move money away from progressive causes and into right-wing organizations.
We should have learned that lesson after the 2024 election, with Democrats’ trying to build solidarity with the right wing (by bringing conservative speakers to the stage and talking about having the “most lethal military on earth,” for instance) while actively dismissing anti-genocide protests and preventing Palestinian leaders from having any speaking slots. We lost millions of progressive voters while trying to court those who would never vote for a Democrat.
This is not to say that we shouldn't ever try to reach those on the complete opposite end of the spectrum in values; but we should never prioritize them over people and organizations who are closer to our goals and visions.
Solidary is absolutely vital to our work. But we must have a stronger grounding on with whom we are building that solidarity. It was by building solidary among progressives, Gen Z, and voters of color that created the Blue Wave, and not because we reached out to MAGA voters.
And it’s by building solidarity with those who align with values of justice and equity, not with those who oppose everything progressives stand for, that we will achieve a just and equitable world.
--
Thank you to monthly Patreon supporters and Ghost subscribers for keeping these posts ad-free and open to everyone...and not written with any intentional help from AI (Please ignore the typos, run-on sentences, nonsensical metaphors, and other human errors).